大数跨境

We are what we eat有机食物真的更健康更环保吗?

We are what we eat有机食物真的更健康更环保吗? 燕窝英语学习乐园
2018-09-05
0
导读:Next time you see organic produce in stores, don't just swallow the marketing campaign without some

Is Organic Food Worth the Cost?


I’m Bjorn Lomborg, president of the Copenhagen Consensus Center.



Is Organic Food Worth the Cost?


“You are what you eat,” goes the old saying. And everywhere we are urged to eat organic: it’s more nutritious, pesticide-free, and protects animals and the environment. At least, that’s what we are being told – or rather, sold. And thanks to a lot of very effective marketing, many people believe it. That’s why, when researchers at Cornell University gave study participants a choice between two identical items, one labeled “organic” and one “regular,” the participants confidently declared the “organic” choice to be lower in calories and more nutritious. They also said they’d pay 16 to 23 percent more for the organic choice. But these beliefs about organic food have nothing to do with reality.


In 2012, Stanford University’s Center for Health Policy did the most comprehensive comparison and found organic foods are not nutritionally superior to conventional alternatives. And a more recent review of 20 years of research into animal products by Italian researchers confirmed these findings. The authors concluded: “Scientific studies do not show that organic products are more nutritious and safer than conventional foods.”


That’s fine, you might say. You don’t eat organic foods just because of the health benefits, but because you care about the treatment of farm animals and of the environment. Unfortunately, the facts don’t support these beliefs either.


Animals on organic farms are not generally healthier than animals on regular farms. A five-year US study of dairy farms showed that “health outcomes [for animals on organic farms] are similar to conventional dairies.” And the Norwegian Scientific Committee for Food Safety reached a similar conclusion. It found “no difference in objective disease occurrence” on organic dairy farms as compared to conventional dairies. And while pigs and poultry on organic farms may enjoy better access to open areas, this freedom, studies show, also increases their exposure to parasites, pathogens and predators.


As for the environment, yes, organic farming will mean that in any one field, a farmer will use less energy and create fewer greenhouse gases. But there’s a problem here. By forgoing fertilizers and pesticides, organic farming is much, much less efficient than standard farming, which means that organic farmers need much more land to grow the same amount of food.

A major study in Europe found that to produce the same gallon of milk organically, you need 59% more land. To produce meat, you need 82% more land. And for crops, it’s more than 200%.


And more land for agriculture means less land for nature. If U.S. agricultural production was entirely organic, it would mean we would need to convert an area bigger than the size of California entirely to farmland. Economically, the lower productivity of organics means we have to commit more resources – land, labor and capital. The total cost to the US economy of going organic would run to about $200 billion annually. 


But, surely organic food means no pesticides, right? Wrong. Organic farming can use any pesticide that is “natural.” Natural pesticides include, for example, copper sulphate and Pyreethrin. The former has resulted in liver disease in vineyard sprayers in France, according to a 1996 study; and the latter, a 3.7-fold increase in leukemia among farmers who handled it compared to those who had not, according to a 2002 study.


Yes, it is true that non-organic foods carry a higher risk of pesticide contamination. But that risk is almost non-existent. Rough calculations suggest that all the pesticides on food eaten by Americans may cause around 20 extra cancer deaths per year. You have a similar chance of being mauled to death by a cow.

In sum, organic food is not healthier for you, nor is it better for animals and the environment than conventionally farmed food. I know this goes against everything you have come to believe, but that only proves the power of marketing. Organic food is a First World luxury. And while buying it is just as valid as any other luxury purchase, one should resist any implied moral superiority – as, for example, when fashion designer Vivienne Westwood famously exclaimed that people who can’t afford organic food should “eat less.”


Unfortunately, a lot of people in the developing world don’t have the option of eating less. They worry about eating, period. To do that, they need access to cheaper food, which means more access to effective fertilizers and pesticides.


So, next time you see organic produce at the supermarket, don’t just swallow the marketing campaign without some critical thought.


I’m Bjorn Lomborg, president of the Copenhagen Consensus Center.

内容来自网络


是培养批判性思维的好材料哦

资料寻找和整理很费时间和精力,如果你正好需要这个视频和文字材料,请赞赏5元后留言信箱获取哦


你也许还喜欢


读后续写教学案例12:2018年6月高考续写真题

我的下水作文

课件分享Book 4 Unit 1 A Student of African Wildlife

人教必修4第一单元课外补充材料

读后续写微技能之Show, don't tell

读后续写素材积累之环境描写等

干货!2018年高考英语满分作文及试题分析汇总

应用文学习之招聘启事

停课了,英语你还能复习啥?

六月高考一结束,十月高考也就不远了

新高考中的高分作文长啥样

浙江新高考后的四次续写

考前讲座之续写篇

考前讲座之概要篇

应用文写作:谈“家风”

人物介绍的写作:从模仿到创作,你需要的是积累

公开课之“Make Music with Three Strings”

公开课之“The Secret to Education”PPT、教学设计和学案

公开课之“Satisfaction Guaranteed”PPT

文学作品公开课和教学设计: 高文和绿骑士

绘本选修课:Unit 4 Courage

我的绘本选修课Unit1

我的绘本选修课上的看图写话

我的自编选修教材:let's debate

关于邀请函你应该知道的套路

高考作文复习PPT系列之道歉信

修改扩容后的应用文课件PPT新鲜出炉了---感谢信~~~


【声明】内容源于网络
0
0
燕窝英语学习乐园
1234
内容 1759
粉丝 0
燕窝英语学习乐园 1234
总阅读0
粉丝0
内容1.8k