最早在教材上读到一篇文章,引起我思考的是The earth is becoming warmer--but does it matter?也是从那个时候开始,了解了critical thinking,明白当我们听到一种声音的时候,不要急于全盘接受,还要思考,同时听听另一种声音。

下面就是我在模拟卷中读到的一篇很好的阅读文章,值得大家思考,也是培养批评性思维的好素材,所以花了时间把它做成了教材。
Conservation or Wasted Effort
Reading Text
The black robin is one of the world's rarest birds. It is a small, wild bird, and it lives only on the island of Little Mangere,off the coast of
Energetic steps are being taken to preserve the black robin. Detailed studies are going on, and a public appeal for money has been made. The idea is to buy another island nearby as a special home, a "reserve", for threatened wildlife, including black robins. The organizers say that Little Mangere should then be supplied with the robin's food — it eats only one kind of seed.Thousands of the required plants are at present being cultivated in
Is all this concern a waste of human effort? Is it any business of ours whether the black robin survives or dies out? Are we losing our sense of what is reasonable and what is unreasonable?
In the earth's long, long past,hundreds of kinds of creatures have evolved,risen to a degree of success — and died out. In the long, long future, there will be many new and different forms of life. Those creatures that adapt themselves successfully to what the earth offers will survive for a long time.Those that fail to meet the challenges will disappear early. This is nature's proven method of operation.
The rule of selection — "the survival of the fittest" — is the one by which human beings have themselves arrived on the scene. We, being one of the most adaptable creatures the earth has yet produced, may last longer than most. You may take it as another rule that when, at last, human beings show signs of dying out, no other creature will extend a paw to put off our departure. On the contrary, we will be hurried out. For nature, though fair, is a hard-hearted mistress. She has no favorites.
Life seems to have grown too tough for black robins. I leave you to judge whether we should try to do something about it.
Reading guidance
——on the author:an unknown author
——on the passage:It is a passage of critical thinking. Whether we should protect the black robin or leave it to the rule of selection, the writer raises his opinion and gives evidence to support it.
——on the background information of blackrobins:The black robin is an endangered bird from the ChathamIslands off the east coast of New Zealand.It is closely related to the NewZealand robin. It was first described by Walter Buller a
Little Mangere is privately owned and was once the last refuge of the few remaining Black robinuntil they were transferred to nearby Mangere Island and South East Island as part of a species recoveryplan in the early 1980s.
——on the theory of natural selection: the gradual process by which biological traits become either more orless common in a population as a function of the effect of inherited traits onthe differential reproductive success of organisms interacting with their environment. It is a key mechanism of evolution. The term "natural selection" was popularized by Charles Darwin who intended it to be compared with artificial selection, now more commonly referred to as selective breeding.
——on the genre:
1. The framework of the argumentative passage

4. three steps of raising an argument
raise a topic---supporting details---conclusion
Reading notes
——Acquisition to your vocabulary
1.multiply: ['mʌltɪplaɪ] v. (biology 生) to reproduce in large numbers; to make sth do this (使)繁殖,增殖
eg. It is possible to multiply these bacteriain the laboratory.
在实验室里繁殖这些细菌是有可能的。
2.appeal: [ə'pi:l] [C, U] ~ (to sb) (for sth), ~ to sb to do sth an urgent and deeply felt request for money, help or information,especially one made by a charity or by the police (尤指慈善机构或警方的)呼吁,吁请,恳求
eg. The child's mother made an emotional appeal on TV for his return.
孩子的母亲在电视里动情地恳求孩子回来。
【高考链接】11. The good thing about children is that they__________ very easily to new environments. (2009浙江) (A)
Aadapt B appeal C attach D apply
3.reserve: [rɪ'zɜ:v] n. an area of land where the animals, birds, and plants are officially protected. (野生生物)保护区
eg. Marine biologists are calling for Cardigan Bay to be created a marine nature reserve to protect the dolphins.
海洋生物学家号召将卡迪根湾建成一个海洋自然保护区,以保护那里的海豚。
【高考链接】28.I’dprefer to_____ my judgement until I find all the evidence. (2011福建) (D)
A.show B. express C.pass D.reserve
4.threaten: ['θretn] v. If something or someone threatens a person or thing, they are likely to harm that person or thing. 危害到;威胁到
30 percent of reptiles, birds, and fish are currently threatened with extinction.
目前,30% 的爬行动物、鸟类和鱼类面临灭绝的危险。
5.cultivate: ['kʌltɪveɪt] v. to grow plants or crops 种植;栽培;培育
eg. The people in this part of the world cultivate mainly rice and beans.
这里的人们主要种植水稻和豆类。
6. conscience: ['kɒnʃəns] n. C, U] the part of your mind that tells you whether your actions are right or wrong 良心;良知
eg. After he had committed the crime, his conscience was troubled.
他犯罪后,良心上感到很不安。
——Acquisition to your expressions
1. take steps to do sth.: take measures step by step to dosth. 采取步骤做某事
eg. They have taken steps to protect the endangered animals in this area from dying out.
他们已经采取措施保护这一区的濒危动物使它们免于灭绝。
2.make an appeal for: deal severely with呼吁(大家)做某事
eg. He made an appeal for protecting the river in the village.
他呼吁大家保护这个村子里的这条河。
3.supply sb. with sth: provide sb. with sth.; offersb. sth.提供某人某物
eg. The gas station usually supplies its nearby communities with gas.
这个加油站供应附近的社区居民汽油。
4.be aimed at: have …as a plan or intention目标,旨在……
eg. Our marketing campaign should be aimed at young working couples。
我们的市场营销的目标应该定位在年轻的工薪夫妇。
5.die out: become extinct; come to a complete end灭绝
eg. With the development of science and technology, many old customs are gradually dying out.
随着科技的发展,许多老的习俗正在逐渐消亡。
Analyzing & Exploring
——Analyzing the structure& plot
1. What does the title mean? What will the writer talk about in the passage?
2. What is the writing style of the passage?
A.narrative writing B. argumentative writing
C. essay D. expositive writing
3. The writer's attitude towards the protection of the black robins is ________.
A. active B. passive C. unconcerned D.optimistic
4. The black robin is dying out mainly because________.
A. people have been very careless about its survival
B. its only food supply is far from enough on Little Mangere
C. the other birds on the island have destroyed it
D. the appeal for money has come at the wrong time
——Exploring the writer’s idea
1. As for selection and survival, the decisive factor seems to be________.
A. the ability to adapt to changed or changing conditions
B. the number of wild life reserves that are available
C. the concern and generosity of the public
D. the size of the home, or the amount of space one has to live in
2. In Paragraph 3, the writer puts forward three questions to _________.
A. make a comparison B. make anargument
C.introduce a topic D. present his own idea
3. How is the passage organized?
Appreciating & Assessing
——Appreciating language
1. comparison
At the end of the passage, the writer put forward the rule of selection to compare the situation of humanswith that of the black robin, so that the writer makes it clear that only thosefittest can survive long enough.
2. Contrast
Some animals that can not adapt to the new environment have died out, so will the black robin if it can not adapt to the changes in the environment.
—— Learning thegolden lines by heart(six sentences)
1. Energetic steps are being taken to preserve the black robin.
2. Detailed studies are going on, and a public appeal for money has been made.
3. Those that fail to meet the challenges will disappear early.
4. This is nature's proven method of operation.
5. For nature, though fair, is a hard-hearted mistress.
6. She has no favorites.
——Exploring the writer’s techniques
• Learn to present the opinion by raising questions.
• Learn to raise supporting details by giving comparisons and contrast
• Learn to use an accepted rule as the base of the argument.
Creative writing & Assessing
Debate: To make efforts to protect the endangered species or to leave them to the rule of selection?
Writing: let it be or protect it?
The following expressions may help you.
set up natural reserves
face the danger of extinction
die out…
fail to meet the challenge
the rule of selection …
the survival of the fittest
adapt to the change
the theory of evolution
let it be
leave it to your judgment
wasted efforts
take steps to do sth.
make an appeal for …
Extensive reading& writing
——Extensive reading reference
Zoos,good or bad for animals?
——Extensive writing
Write a passage to the newspaper to call onthe people to protect the endangered species.
















拓展阅读文章
Zoos, good or bad foranimals?
How could we possibly think that keeping animals in cages in unnatural environments-mostly for entertainment purposes-is fair and respectful?
Zoo officials say they are concerned about animals. However, most zoos remain “collections” of interesting “things” rather than protective habitats. Zoos teach people that it is acceptable to keep animals bored, lonely, and far from their natural homes.
Zoos claim to educate people and save endangered species, but visitors leave zoos without having learned anything meaningful about the animals’ natural behavior, intelligence, or beauty. Zoos keep animals in small spaces or cages, and most signs only mention the species’name, diet, and natural range. The animals’ normal behavior is seldom noticed because zoos don’t usually take care of the animals’ natural needs.
The animals are kept together in small spaces, with no privacy and little opportunity for mental and physical exercise. This results in unusual and self-destructive behavior called zoochosis. A worldwide study of zoos found that zoochosis is common among animals kept in small spaces or cages. Another study showed that elephants spend 22 percent of their time making repeated head movements or biting cage bars, and bears spend 30 percent of their time walking back and forth, a sign of unhappiness and pain.
Furthermore, most animals in zoos are not endangered. Captive breeding(圈养繁殖)of endangered big cats, Asian elephants, and other species has not resulted in their being sent back to the wild. Zoos talk a lot about their captive breeding programs because they do not want people to worry about a species dying out. In fact, baby animals also attract a lot of paying customers. Haven’t we seen enough competitions to name baby animals?
Actually, we will save endangered species only if we save their habitats and put an end to the reasons people kill them.Instead of supporting zoos, we should support groups that work to protect animals’ natural habitats.
Questions for consideration:
1. How would the author describe the animals' life in zoos?
2. What does the author try to argue in the passage?
3. What is your own opinion on keeping animals in the zoo?

扫码并留下邮箱获取该教材和课外拓展阅读内容(word)和课件内容(PPT)
读后续写教学案例12:2018年6月高考续写真题
我的下水作文
课件分享Book 4 Unit 1 A Student of African Wildlife
人教必修4第一单元课外补充材料
人教必修4第一单元课外补充材料(2)
人教必修4第二单元课外补充材料
We are what we eat有机食物真的更健康更环保吗?
是时候学习点修辞手法了~~~
读后续写微技能之Show, don't tell
读后续写素材积累之环境描写等
干货!2018年高考英语满分作文及试题分析汇总
应用文学习之招聘启事
停课了,英语你还能复习啥?
六月高考一结束,十月高考也就不远了
新高考中的高分作文长啥样
浙江新高考后的四次续写
考前讲座之续写篇
考前讲座之概要篇
应用文写作:谈“家风”
人物介绍的写作:从模仿到创作,你需要的是积累
公开课之“Make Music with Three Strings”
公开课之“The Secret to Education”PPT、教学设计和学案
公开课之“Satisfaction Guaranteed”PPT
文学作品公开课和教学设计: 高文和绿骑士
绘本选修课:Unit 4 Courage
我的绘本选修课Unit1
我的绘本选修课上的看图写话
我的自编选修教材:let's debate
关于邀请函你应该知道的套路
高考作文复习PPT系列之道歉信
修改扩容后的应用文课件PPT新鲜出炉了---感谢信~~~

