小提示:点击上面蓝色“营销电商文献速递”即可一键关注
【文献速递】Journal of Consumer Research,Volume 53, Issue 3, October 2026
采编:储思蓉 校对:莫海鑫 终审:邵兵家目 录
1.Insiders Only: Are Our Ideas about What Makes “Good Theory” Holding Us Back?
仅限圈内人:我们对“好理论”的固有认知是否在阻碍我们?
2.Painful Prices: The Moral Harm Model of Price Fairness
痛苦的价格:价格公平的道德伤害模型
3.Limiting Accessibility: How Targeting Consumers with Disabilities Constrains Acceptable Prices for Innovations
限制可及性:面向残障消费者的定位如何制约创新产品的可接受价格
4.This Article Is Not for Everyone: The Impact of Dissuasive Framing on Consumer Response to Product Messages
本文并非适合所有人:劝阻性框架对消费者产品信息反应的影响
5.The Confirmation Nudge: Prompts to Change or Confirm Initial Preferences Steer Consumer Choice
确认助推:改变或确认初始偏好的提示对消费者选择的引导作用
6.How Perceptual Disfluency Affects Consumer Choices
感知不流畅如何影响消费者选择
7.The (Better) Road Not Taken: Setting a Goal Reduces Switching to More Effective Alternatives
未选择的(更好)道路:设定目标会减少向更有效替代方案的切换
8.Beauty as a Goal: Creating Harmony Between Health and Taste
美感作为目标:实现健康与美味的平衡
9.Sustainability Cues Can Delay Consumption
可持续性线索可能延迟消费行为
10.Brief Commentary: A Framework for Detecting AI Agents in Online Research
摘 要
1.Insiders Only: Are Our Ideas about What Makes “Good Theory” Holding Us Back?
仅限圈内人:我们对“好理论”的固有认知是否在阻碍我们?
作者:John G Lynch, Stijn M J van Osselaer和Patricia Torres
Abstract: Consumer researchers often prize relevance but overlook how narrow assumptions about good theory limit it. Much work focuses on construct-to-construct theorizing, which involves introducing new constructs or new links among them. Far less valued is phenomenon-to-construct theorizing, which begins with real-world patterns and seeks to explain them by identifying the underlying active ingredient constructs. Examples include why GMO labels reduce demand or why drip pricing leads people to choose higher-cost options. Our survey of authors in four leading journals shows that most believe only construct-to-construct work counts as theory. We argue that this view is too narrow. Drawing on a Bayesian framework for updating beliefs within a theoretical network, we show that phenomenon-to-construct theorizing follows the same logic of scientific inference. Both approaches rely on established links in the nomological network to draw stronger conclusions about the focal link of interest. Using well-supported construct-to-construct mechanisms to explain real-world phenomena is therefore a strength, not a weakness. We clarify how phenomenon-to-construct theorizing differs from both “mere application” and “empirics-first” research. Embracing this form of theorizing can broaden the reach of consumer research by connecting abstract ideas to meaningful, actionable phenomena that matter to scholars, practitioners, and policymakers.
摘要:消费者研究者常常重视相关性,却忽视了对好理论的狭隘认知假设带来了何种限制。现有大量研究聚焦于构念—构念理论建构模式,即引入新构念或构念之间的新联系。相比之下,现象—构念理论建构模式所受到的重视远远不足,后者从现实世界现象规律出发,试图通过识别潜在的底层活性成分构念来解释。例如,转基因标签为何会降低消费需求,或阶梯定价为何会导致人们选择成本更高的选项。我们对四本顶级期刊作者进行的调查显示,大多数人认为只有构念与构念之间的研究才算理论。我们认为这种观点过于狭隘。本文借助理论网络内信念更新的贝叶斯框架证明,现象—构念的理论建构遵循同样的科学推断逻辑。两种方法都依赖法则网络中已确立的联系,来对关注的焦点联系得出更强有力的结论。因此,利用得到充分支持的构念与构念机制来解释现实世界现象是一种优势,而非弱点。我们阐明了现象—构念的理论建构与“单纯应用”和“实证优先”研究之间的区别。接纳这种理论建构形式可以通过将抽象观念与对学者、实践者和政策制定者而言有意义、可行动的现象联系起来,拓宽消费者研究的辐射范围。
2.Painful Prices: The Moral Harm Model of Price Fairness
痛苦的价格:价格公平的道德伤害模型
作者:Margaret C Campbell, Justin Pomerance和Erin L Percival Carter
Abstract: Consumers’ responses to seller’s prices, including perceptions of price fairness (PPF) and unfairness, are a crucial aspect of the marketplace. Although past literature has uncovered a variety of factors that influence PPF, the lack of an overarching conceptual framework has constrained understanding of when and why consumers are more likely to perceive prices as fair or unfair. The authors develop a conceptual model of PPF as moral judgments and propose that these moral PPF arise from consumer inferences of potential harm from a price. The conceptualization suggests that inferred harm—and thereby, PPF—is influenced by consumer vulnerability, product welfare impact and firm price strategy (e.g., costs and prices, differential pricing, and price promotions). The authors also propose that consumer political orientation and inferred firm self-defense motives moderate the relationship between inferred harm and PPF and that inferred firm motives for prices influence PPF. Eight studies test this conceptualization. The results support the moral harm model and provide novel insights, showing when unchanged prices, price increases, and price decreases are likely to be perceived as more unfair and when differential prices (including paying more than others) are likely to be perceived as fairer than equal prices.
摘要:消费者对卖方价格的回应,包括价格公平感知(PPF)和不公平感知,是市场中的一个关键方面。尽管过往文献揭示了影响PPF的各种因素,但缺乏一套整体性概念框架,限制了我们理解消费者何时以及为何更可能将价格感知为公平或不公平。本文将价格公平感知视为道德判断的概念模型,并提出这些道德性价格公平感知源于消费者对价格潜在伤害的推断。该理论模型表明,推断伤害(进而影响价格公平感知)受到消费者脆弱性、产品福利影响和企业价格策略(如成本与价格、差别定价和价格促销)的影响。同时,消费者政治倾向和推断的企业自我防卫动机会调节推断伤害与价格公平感知之间的关系,并且推断的企业价格动机会直接影响价格公平感知。本文通过八项研究对该理论概念开展检验。结果支持道德伤害模型,并提供了新的结论:不变价格、价格上涨和价格下降何时可能被感知为更不公平,以及差别价格(包括比他人支付更多)何时可能被感知为比同等价格更公平。
3.Limiting Accessibility: How Targeting Consumers with Disabilities Constrains Acceptable Prices for Innovations
限制可及性:面向残障消费者的定位如何制约创新产品的可接受价格
作者:Musa Essa, Johannes Boegershausen和Gabriele Paolacci
Abstract: People with disabilities constitute 15% of the world’s population with a total disposable income of more than $2.6 trillion. However, few companies offer products tailored to the needs of this segment, making it important to understand how mass-market consumers react to innovations that target people with disabilities. Nine studies and six supplementary studies (twelve preregistered) reveal that innovations targeting consumers with disabilities are subject to comparatively greater scrutiny by mass-market consumers. Specifically, consumers find charging price premiums for innovative products less acceptable when they are targeted at people with disabilities. The aversion to targeting this segment occurs only when firms charge a price premium and persists even when firms provide cost justifications for the relatively higher prices. Drawing on research on disability stereotypes, we identify pity for people with disabilities as a critical driver of these reactions. Variations in pity across disabilities are related to the acceptability of a price premium for adaptive innovations. These findings are suggestive of a novel form of paternalism against consumers with disabilities. Paradoxically, this view may render the marketplace less inclusive for consumers with disabilities, as it could penalize companies that provide more options for this underserved segment.
摘要:残障人士占世界人口的15%,总可支配收入超过2.6万亿美元。然而,很少有公司提供针对这一群体需求定制的产品,因此理解大众市场消费者如何回应针对残障人士的创新非常重要。九项研究和六项补充研究(其中十二项预注册)揭示,针对残障消费者的创新会受到大众市场消费者相对更大的审视。具体而言,当创新产品针对残障人士时,消费者认为为其收取价格溢价更不可接受。对以这一群体为目标的厌恶仅在企业收取价格溢价时出现,并且即使企业为相对较高的价格提供成本理由也依然存在。借鉴关于残障刻板印象的研究,我们发现对残障群体的同情心理是上述反应的关键驱动因素。不同残障类型之间同情程度的差异与适应性创新价格溢价的可接受性相关。研究结果揭示了一种针对残障消费者的新型家长主义现象。颇具悖论的是,这种社会认知反而会降低市场对残障消费者的包容性,企业若为这一供给不足的群体开发更多产品,反而有可能遭受市场的负面惩罚。
4.This Article Is Not for Everyone: The Impact of Dissuasive Framing on Consumer Response to Product Messages
本文并非适合所有人:劝阻性框架对消费者产品信息反应的影响
作者:Karen Anne Wallach, Sean Blair和Jaclyn L Tanenbaum
Abstract: Conventional wisdom and past research converge on the notion that product messages are more effective when they use a persuasive frame that directly addresses the product’s target customers to indicate a preference match (e.g., “If you like dark coffee, this is the coffee for you!”). In contrast, the current research identifies scenarios where consumers respond more favorably to dissuasive frames—that is, to messages that address the consumers not targeted by the product to indicate a preference mismatch (e.g., “If you don’t like dark coffee, this is not the coffee for you!”). Eight experiments using mixed methods demonstrate that the impact of dissuasive framing on consumer response is positive for target customers and negative for nontarget customers. This occurs because dissuasive framing increases perceptions of the product as a specialized offering intended for a more narrowly defined target segment (i.e., target specificity). Target specificity, in turn, increases (vs. decreases) the perceived fit between the product and target (vs. nontarget) customers, which drives their response. This research sheds light on a novel form of framing and introduces target specificity as a construct with important implications for consumers’ perceptions of fit with a product and their downstream responses.
摘要:传统观点和过往研究普遍认为:当产品信息使用直接针对产品目标顾客的劝服性框架来表明偏好匹配时(例如,“如果你喜欢深烘焙咖啡,这就是适合你的咖啡!”),信息会更有效。相比之下,当前研究识别出消费者对劝阻性框架反应更有利的情境——即针对非产品目标消费者的信息,以表明偏好不匹配(例如,“如果你不喜欢深烘焙咖啡,这不是适合你的咖啡!”)。八项使用混合方法的实验表明,劝阻性框架对消费者反应的影响对目标顾客为正,对非目标顾客为负。这是因为劝阻性框架增加了产品是面向更狭窄定义的目标细分市场的专业化产品的感知(即目标特异性)。目标特异性反过来增加(相对于减少)产品与目标(相对于非目标)顾客之间的感知匹配,从而驱动他们的反应。本研究揭示了一种新颖的框架形式,并引入目标特异性作为一个对消费者产品匹配感知及其下游反应具有重要意义的构念。
5.The Confirmation Nudge: Prompts to Change or Confirm Initial Preferences Steer Consumer Choice
确认助推:改变或确认初始偏好的提示对消费者选择的引导作用
作者:Kellen Mrkva, Shannon M Duncan, Marissa A Sharif和Stanley Zuo
Abstract: Across two field experiments and several preregistered lab experiments, we demonstrate that confirmation nudges, which ask consumers whether they would like to confirm or change their initial choice, impact choice. First, consumers navigating a subscription company’s smartphone app were randomized to a control or confirmation nudge condition, which asked them to either confirm their initial choice or switch to an annual subscription. Confirmation nudges increased subscribers’ choice of the annual subscription by over 8 percentage points—an effect size similar to default effects tested by the same company. In experiment 2, conducted by a jewelry retailer, confirmation nudges had countervailing effects, increasing purchases of a nudged service plan add-on but decreasing originally planned jewelry purchases likely because it added a step and thus frictions to the purchase process. Confirmation nudges had larger effects when nudged options were desirable and among consumers who would benefit from the nudge (experiments 3 and 4). However, they were perceived as more manipulative than comparison conditions (experiment 5). We suggest that confirmation nudges undo tendencies to focus on initially preferred options, shifting attention toward alternatives relative to control conditions. Consistent with this, confirmation nudges were especially effective when the wording of the confirmation prompt focused on the “switch” option.
摘要:本文通过两项现场实验和若干预注册实验室实验证明,确认助推(询问消费者是否愿意确认或改变其初始选择)会影响消费者选择。首先,在订阅公司智能手机应用中,导航的消费者被随机分配到控制组或确认助推组,后者要求他们确认初始选择或切换到年度订阅。确认助推使订阅者选择年度订阅的比例增加了超过8个百分点——这一效应量与同一公司测试的默认效应相似。在由一家珠宝零售商进行的实验2中,确认助推产生了相互抵消的效应,增加了对被助推的服务计划附加项的购买,但减少了原本计划的珠宝购买,很可能是因为它增加了一个操作步骤,从而给购买过程增加了决策摩擦。当被助推的选项具有吸引力时,以及在对助推会受益的消费者中,确认助推的效应更大(实验3和实验4)。然而,与比较条件相比,它们被感知为更具操纵性(实验5)。我们认为,确认助推消除了专注于最初偏好选项的倾向,相对于控制条件将注意力转向替代选项。与此一致,当确认提示的措辞聚焦于“切换”选项时,确认助推尤其有效。
6.How Perceptual Disfluency Affects Consumer Choices
感知不流畅如何影响消费者选择
作者:Shahryar Mohsenin和Kurt P Munz
Abstract: Marketing materials often create difficulties for consumers through elements like unconventional fonts or distracting background images, leading to perceptual disfluency—a sense of difficulty encoding information. During choices, consumers can mistake perceptual disfluency for choice difficulty, a feeling of indecision. Building on this idea, 11 preregistered experiments (N = 9,042) show that when making choices, perceptual disfluency can lead consumers to rely on information that feels more intuitively appealing to them, such as a familiar brand, a preferred country of origin, or a recommendation, rather than on information they must carefully consider like numerical product specifications. Differing from the effect of perceptual disfluency in other situations, during choices, this effect occurs because consumers process information less deeply, engaging in relatively more intuitive and less analytical processing. This effect is amplified when consumers endorse a “fast-is-accurate” lay theory. In contrast, it does not occur when consumers do not mistake perceptual disfluency for choice difficulty, as when prompted to consider the actual reason for the disfluency, or when not making a choice.
摘要:营销材料常常通过非常规字体或分散注意力的背景图片等元素给消费者带来阅读障碍,导致感知不流畅(一种编码信息时的困难感)。消费者进行决策时可能将感知不流畅误认为选择困难,即一种犹豫不决的感觉。基于这一观点,11项预注册实验(N = 9,042)表明,在做出选择时,感知不流畅会导致消费者更多依赖直觉吸引力更强的信息,如熟悉的品牌、偏好的原产国或他人推荐,而放弃需要审慎思考的数值类产品规格信息。与其他情境中感知不流畅的效应不同,在选择过程中,这一效应的产生是因为消费者对信息的加工更浅,进行相对更直觉、更少分析性的加工。当消费者认同“快即准确”的朴素理论时,这一效应会被放大。相比之下,当消费者没有将感知不流畅误认为选择困难时,例如被提示考虑不流畅的实际原因时,或在不做选择时,这一效应不会出现。
7.The (Better) Road Not Taken: Setting a Goal Reduces Switching to More Effective Alternatives
未选择的(更好)道路:设定目标会减少向更有效替代方案的切换
作者:Elizabeth M S Friedman, Guy Voichek和Ravi Dhar
Abstract: We identify a novel way in which setting goals can backfire. In 13 studies and 4 supplemental studies, using both incentive-compatible and hypothetical designs across a range of domains, we demonstrate that setting an explicit goal and making progress toward it decreases the likelihood of switching to alternative means of pursuit. This occurs because means seem more effective relative to alternatives if they have been used to progress toward a reference point. Consistent with this mechanism, we show that the perceived effectiveness of the means used to pursue a goal, relative to an alternative, partially mediates the effect of setting a goal on the decision to switch means. Furthermore, the effect occurs only after people make initial progress toward a specified reference point. Setting a goal does not decrease switching if people are reminded to consider the advantages of both the initial and alternative means. We conclude with a discussion of the theoretical and practical implications of our findings.
摘要:本文揭示了设定目标产生反效果的一种全新机制。通过13项研究和4项补充研究,在多个领域场景下同时使用激励兼容和假设性设计,研究发现设定明确目标并朝其取得进展会降低切换到替代追求手段的可能性。原因在于如果某一手段已被用于向参照点取得进展,那么相对于替代方案,它似乎更有效。与这一机制一致,我们表明,用于追求目标的手段相对于替代方案的感知有效性,部分中介了设定目标对切换手段决策的影响。此外,这一效应仅在人们对指定参照点取得初步进展之后出现。如果人们被提醒考虑初始手段和替代手段两者的优势,设定目标不会减少切换。我们最后讨论了发现的理论和实践意义。
8.Beauty as a Goal: Creating Harmony Between Health and Taste
美感作为目标:实现健康与美味的平衡
作者:Eda Erensoy, Louise Lu, Jennifer Aaker和Ayelet Fishbach
Abstract: People frequently perceive a trade-off between health and taste, leading to poor dietary choices. This research identifies a novel pathway to healthier eating: seeking beauty in food. Across seven preregistered field and lab studies, pursuing beautiful food systematically increased healthy choices without diminishing perceived taste. This effect arises because beauty is positively associated with both health and taste, effectively creating health–taste harmony instead of the commonly perceived conflict. Individuals who sought beauty in food consistently selected healthier options across diverse consumption contexts—including cafeteria meals, self-generated food ideas, grocery lists, and varied menus (with and without images)—and across populations, spanning both adults and children. Notably, the effect was stronger among individuals who more strongly associate beauty with health and weaker in choice sets in which the beauty–health association was less pronounced (e.g., morning cereals). These findings advance motivation theory by positioning beauty as a goal in itself, rather than merely a perceptual cue. We discuss theoretical and managerial implications for consumer behavior, food marketing, and public policy initiatives aimed at promoting healthier eating.
摘要:消费者往往认为健康与美味二者不可兼得,由此产生不健康的饮食决策。本研究提出促进健康饮食的一条新路径:在食物中寻求美。在七项预注册的现场和实验室研究中,追求美丽的食物系统性地增加了健康选择,而没有降低感知美味。这一效应的产生是因为美与健康和美味都正相关,有效地创造了健康美味平衡,而不是通常感知到的对立冲突。在食物中寻求美的个体在不同消费情境中,包括自助餐厅餐食、自我生成的食物想法、购物清单和多样化菜单(有图和无图)以及不同人群中(涵盖成人和儿童)都始终选择更健康的选项。值得注意的是,这一效应在更强烈地将美与健康联系起来的个体中更强,而在美感—健康关联不那么明显的选择集中更弱(例如,早餐麦片)。这些发现通过将美定位为自身的目标,而不仅仅是感知线索,推进了动机理论。我们讨论了其对消费者行为、食品营销和旨在促进更健康饮食的公共政策倡议的理论和管理意义。
9.Sustainability Cues Can Delay Consumption
可持续性线索可能延迟消费行为
作者:Feifei Huang, Rafay A Siddiqui和Qianqian (Esther) Liu
Abstract: With the rise of environmental concerns in recent decades, many companies have joined the initiative to advertise and promote sustainable consumption. The current research examines how providing sustainability cues to consumers might have unintended consequences of which practitioners and policymakers may not be fully aware. One pilot study and 10 main studies, including two real-choice studies, show that a sustainability cue may delay consumption. That is, in an intertemporal choice, a sustainability cue can increase preference for a larger-later option over a smaller-sooner option. This effect occurs because a sustainability cue shifts a consumer’s temporal focus toward the future, leading to a shorter perceived wait time for the larger-later option. The findings further show that the delay does not emerge among those with strong green consumption values and can be circumvented if firms communicate the immediate need or instant payoff of sustainable actions. By investigating how sustainability cues shift consumer preferences between two options separated in time, the current research contributes to the literature on both sustainable consumption and intertemporal choice. The findings offer practitioners and policymakers guidelines to nudge consumers’ sustainable consumption more effectively.
摘要:近几十年来随着环境关注的兴起,许多公司加入了宣传和促进可持续消费的行列。当前研究考察了向消费者提供可持续性线索可能产生的意外后果,而实践者和政策制定者可能并未充分意识到这些后果。一项试点研究和10项主要研究,包括两项真实选择研究表明,可持续性线索可能延迟消费行为。即在跨期选择中,可持续性线索可以增加对更大收益——较晚获得选项相对于更小收益——较早获得选项的偏好。这一效应的产生是因为可持续性线索将消费者的时间焦点转向未来,导致对更大收益——较晚获得选项的感知等待时间缩短。研究发现进一步表明,具有强烈绿色消费价值观的人群中不出现该延迟效应,并且如果企业传达可持续行动的即时需求或即时收益,则可以规避。通过考察可持续性线索如何转变消费者在时间上分离的两个选项之间的偏好,当前研究对可持续消费和跨期选择两方面的文献都有贡献。这些发现为实践者和政策制定者更有效地助推消费者可持续消费提供了指南。
10.Brief Commentary: A Framework for Detecting AI Agents in Online Research
短评:在线研究场景下的AI 代理识别框架
作者:Felipe M Affonso
Abstract: Online behavioral research assumes survey responses come from humans, yet vision-enabled AI agents can now autonomously complete surveys by capturing screenshots, processing questions, and submitting responses. Because these agents perceive the same rendered visual content that humans see, traditional detection methods are ineffective. This article introduces the Cognitive Trap Framework: researchers can transform architectural constraints of vision-language models into survey questions where the correct answers are simultaneously difficult for AI agents but easily processed by humans. Six traps derived from computer science benchmarks demonstrate the framework. Against 1,007 human participants (Prolific) and 526 researcher-deployed AI agents (e.g., ChatGPT Agent, Google Project Mariner), cognitive traps detected 97.1% of agents (vs. 2.3% with traditional attention checks), while flagging only 4.1% of humans. Pre-registered replications on Amazon Mechanical Turk and CloudResearch Connect demonstrate cross-platform effectiveness, and validation against 34 frontier models spanning two years reveals that model improvement is non-monotonic because each new architecture reconfigures which constraints it resolves and which it introduces. The framework can thus generate new cognitive traps as AI agent models evolve, and a public repository provides researchers with validated traps ready for deployment.
—END—
声明:本公众号每周一和每周三定期更新,根据需要会不定期增加更新频次。因时间和水平所限,中文译文可能存在不准确之处,欢迎反馈意见给我们。本文版权归原作者及原出处所有,内容为作者观点,并不代表本公众号赞同其观点及对其真实性负责。如涉及版权等问题,请及时与我们联系,我们立即更正或删除相关内容。本公众号拥有对此声明的最终解释权

